Who Pays Closing Costs? Seller Concessions and the Caps That Limit Them

In May 2026, 46.2% of US home sales included a seller concession — the highest May share on record. Asking the seller to cover your closing costs is no longer an unusual move; it is close to the default in much of the country.

But there is a ceiling on how much a seller can contribute, it changes with your loan type and down payment, and the tightest version of it — 3% — applies to exactly the buyers most likely to need help. Blowing through that cap does not just get denied; it forces a recalculation that can kill the deal.

How common concessions actually are, and where

The national figure hides enormous regional variation, and knowing your market matters more than knowing the average.

In May 2026, concessions appeared in 75.5% of Nashville sales, 71.4% in Charlotte and 68.7% in Atlanta. In New York they appeared in 2.9% of sales, San Jose 5.9%, San Francisco 14.9%.

Roughly 15.7% of sales nationally included both a concession and a price cut — also a record for May.

The practical translation: a first-time buyer in Atlanta or Nashville should ask for a concession on essentially every offer, and would be leaving money on the table by not. A buyer in Manhattan or San Jose is wasting negotiating capital by asking.

Concessions get used for three things: covering closing costs, paying for repairs found in inspection, and buying down the mortgage rate. That last one has become common enough to be worth its own conversation with your lender, because a rate buydown paid by the seller can be worth far more over time than the same dollars applied to closing costs.

The caps, by loan type

These are the numbers to know before you write an offer, and they are frequently reported wrong.

Conventional

The cap depends on your down payment, calculated against the lesser of sales price or appraised value:

  • More than 90% loan-to-value — meaning less than 10% down: 3%
  • 75.01% to 90% loan-to-value — 10% to 25% down: 6%
  • 75% or below — 25% or more down: 9%
  • Investment property at any loan-to-value: 2%

Note the shape of that. Put 3% or 5% down and you get a 3% cap. Put 10% down and it doubles to 6%.

On a $350,000 purchase with 5% down, 3% is $10,500 — which in a high-transfer-tax state may not even cover the closing costs, let alone a rate buydown.

FHA

6% of the lesser of sales price or appraised value. Importantly, it cannot be used toward your 3.5% minimum required investment — that has to be your own money or an acceptable gift.

A 2023 proposal to reduce this was never finalized. Six percent remains current.

VA

This one is the most commonly botched fact in consumer content, and understanding it correctly is genuinely valuable.

The VA “concession” cap is 4% of the loan amount — but that 4% is narrow. It covers the VA funding fee, prepaid taxes and insurance, payoff of the buyer’s debts, discount points above 2%, appliances and gifts.

Separately and additionally, the seller may pay unlimited ordinary loan-related closing costs — origination, appraisal, title, attorney fees — without touching the 4% cap at all.

So a VA buyer has far more room than “4%” implies. If someone tells you the seller can only contribute 4% on a VA loan, they are misreading the rule.

USDA

6% of the sales price on guaranteed loans.

What happens if you exceed the cap

This is worth understanding because the consequence is not simply “denied.”

Anything above the cap — plus cash payments, rebates and personal property — is reclassified as a sales concession rather than a financing concession. Sales concessions get deducted from the sale price, and then your loan-to-value is recalculated on the reduced figure.

Work through what that does. On a $350,000 purchase with 5% down and a 3% cap, if the seller agrees to $15,000 in credits, the $4,500 above the cap comes off the price. The loan is now underwritten against $345,500 rather than $350,000, which changes your loan-to-value, may change your mortgage insurance rate, and can push the file out of the box it was approved in.

The deal does not necessarily die, but it has to be restructured — usually late, usually under time pressure. Better to size the ask correctly at the offer stage.

Buyer-agent commission and the cap: the genuinely unsettled part

Since the August 2024 changes to how buyer agents are compensated, a natural question arose: if the seller pays the buyer’s agent, does that count against the concession cap?

The agencies addressed it, and their answers are consistent:

  • Fannie Mae, April 2024: if a seller or seller’s agent continues to pay the buyer’s agent commission in accordance with local common and customary practice, those amounts are not required to count toward the concession limits. Freddie Mac issued matching guidance the same day. Both framed it as clarifying existing policy rather than changing it.
  • FHA, around the same time: if sellers continue to pay buyer-side commissions as a matter of state and local law or custom, and the amounts are reasonable, existing policy would not treat those payments as interested party contributions.
  • VA, effective August 2024: created a variance letting veterans pay reasonable and customary buyer-broker charges. Those charges cannot be financed into the loan and count in the veteran’s assets-to-close. And notably, VA does not treat a seller’s payment of buyer-broker charges as a seller concession at all.
  • USDA: published a *proposed* rule in April 2026 to exclude commission fees from the concession limit. Comments closed in June 2026. It is still a proposal.

The weakness in all of this

Every one of those carve-outs is conditioned on the fee being customarily paid by the seller according to local convention, and reasonable in amount.

The 2024 settlement changes are precisely what erodes “local convention.” As markets shift toward negotiated or buyer-paid compensation, the factual predicate for the exclusion gets weaker — and no agency has published a bright-line test for when a market has flipped. Different lenders and investors apply their own overlays.

Our honest read: assume the exclusion holds, because that is how it is being applied today, but confirm it in writing with your specific lender before you structure an offer that depends on it. This matters most at the 3% cap, where a buyer-agent fee reclassified as a concession would blow through the ceiling and force a price reduction.

That is not a comfortable answer, but it is the accurate one, and anyone telling you this is fully settled has not read the guidance.

Who customarily pays what

Beyond concessions, some costs are allocated by regional custom rather than rule — and custom is negotiable.

  • Transfer taxes — usually the seller, but Delaware splits it, Vermont has the buyer pay, and New York splits transfer tax to the seller and mansion tax to the buyer.
  • Owner’s title policy — the seller pays in roughly 26 states including Texas, Illinois, Michigan, Ohio and Washington. The buyer pays in New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania and North Carolina. California and Florida split by region and county.
  • Lender’s title policy — essentially always the buyer.
  • Appraisal — the buyer, since the lender orders it on the buyer’s file.
  • Home inspection — the buyer.
  • Survey — varies; often the seller in the Southeast, the buyer elsewhere.
  • Recording fees — usually split by document.
  • Real estate commissions — historically the seller; now genuinely negotiable on the buyer side.

The point of that list is not to memorize it. It is that most of it is convention, and conventions get renegotiated in a buyer’s market. Ask your agent what is customary locally, then ask what has actually been happening in recent transactions — those are different questions and the second one is more useful.

How to ask for a concession without losing the house

  1. Find out your cap first. If you are putting less than 10% down on a conventional loan, you have 3% to work with and you need to allocate it deliberately.
  2. Check your market’s concession rate. In Atlanta or Nashville, asking is expected. In San Francisco, it may cost you the deal.
  3. Ask your lender whether a seller-paid rate buydown or seller-paid closing costs is worth more to you. Over a long hold, the buydown usually wins, and most buyers never run the comparison.
  4. Frame it as price. A seller comparing a $350,000 offer with $10,000 in concessions against a $340,000 clean offer is looking at the same net — and often prefers the higher headline number for appraisal and comparable reasons.
  5. Keep the total under your cap with room to spare. Leave a margin so a late repair credit does not push you over.
  6. Get your lender’s position on buyer-agent compensation in writing if your offer depends on the seller paying it.
  7. Use inspection findings as a second, separate conversation. Repair credits negotiated after inspection also count toward the cap, which is exactly where buyers accidentally exceed it.

Frequently asked questions

How much can a seller pay toward my closing costs?

It depends on your loan and down payment. Conventional: 3% with less than 10% down, 6% with 10% to 25% down, 9% above 25%. FHA: 6%. USDA: 6%. VA: 4% for specific concession categories, plus unlimited ordinary loan closing costs on top of that.

What happens if seller concessions exceed the limit?

The excess is reclassified as a sales concession and deducted from the sale price, then your loan-to-value is recalculated on the lower figure. That can change your mortgage insurance rate and push your file outside its approval. It is usually fixable but only by restructuring the deal late, so size the ask correctly upfront.

Do seller-paid buyer agent commissions count against the concession cap?

Under current guidance, generally no. Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, FHA and VA have all indicated that seller payment of buyer-agent compensation consistent with local custom is not treated as an interested party contribution. But every carve-out is conditioned on the fee being customary and reasonable, and no agency defines when a market has stopped being customary. Confirm with your lender in writing before relying on it.

How common are seller concessions right now?

Very, and very regionally. Nationally 46.2% of sales in May 2026 included one — a record for that month. But it was 75.5% in Nashville and 68.7% in Atlanta versus 2.9% in New York and 5.9% in San Jose. Your local rate matters far more than the national figure.

Can seller concessions cover my down payment?

No. Concessions cover closing costs, prepaids, rate buydowns and similar items. On an FHA loan they explicitly cannot be applied to the 3.5% minimum required investment, which must come from your own funds or an acceptable gift. The same principle applies across loan types.

Is it better to ask for a lower price or a concession?

For your monthly payment, usually a concession — especially one applied to a rate buydown, which compounds over the life of the loan in a way a small price cut does not. A $10,000 concession on a $350,000 house typically helps a cash-constrained buyer more than a $10,000 price reduction. Ask your lender to model both.

Who pays for title insurance, the buyer or the seller?

It varies by state and sometimes by county. The seller customarily pays the owner’s policy in about 26 states including Texas, Illinois, Michigan, Ohio and Washington; the buyer pays in New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania and North Carolina. California and Florida split by region. The buyer essentially always pays the lender’s policy.

Do repair credits count toward the concession cap?

Yes, and this is where buyers most often exceed it accidentally. Credits negotiated after inspection stack with whatever closing cost help you already agreed to. Leave margin under your cap at the offer stage so a later repair credit does not push you over.


Keep reading


More on new construction