When you buy an existing home, you usually sign a contract drafted by your state association or a neutral body, with contingencies and deadlines built in to protect both sides. When you buy from a builder, you sign the builder’s own agreement, and it protects the builder.
That is not scandalous — it is what a seller-drafted contract is. But first-time buyers routinely assume the protections they have read about apply, and several of them do not. The most expensive assumption is about the deposit.
What follows is drawn from an actual builder purchase agreement. Terms vary by builder and state, so treat this as the shape of the genre rather than a description of your specific contract — and read yours.
The deposit is probably not refundable
On a resale contract, your deposit is generally refundable if a contingency fails — financing falls through, the inspection turns up something serious, the appraisal comes in low.
Builder contracts frequently work the other way, and they often split the money into two pieces:
- Earnest money, held in escrow, refundable only under narrowly defined triggers — in the contract we reviewed, essentially only if the seller could not deliver title within 45 days or if soil problems required an engineered foundation.
- A separate “construction deposit” that is explicitly not earnest money and explicitly not refundable if the buyer does not close by the closing date.
Builder agreements also commonly omit the loan-objection, appraisal-objection and inspection-objection deadlines and remedies that state resale forms provide as standard.
Put those together and forfeiture becomes the default outcome rather than the exception.
**The single most important line on this page: on a resale contract, assume your deposit is refundable if a contingency fails. On a builder contract, assume it is not, unless the contract says otherwise in writing.**
Two practical consequences. First, never pay a deposit directly to a builder if it can be held in escrow by a neutral third party — a deposit sitting outside escrow is unprotected if the builder becomes insolvent, and an unfinished home with an unrecorded deed leaves you an unsecured creditor. Second, negotiate a financing contingency in explicitly. Many builders will add one, especially on standing inventory, and almost no first-time buyer asks.
The completion date is usually not a date
Builder contracts typically give an estimated occupancy rather than a firm completion date, and state that the actual closing may vary with the construction schedule. Weather and acts of God extend it, and the buyer agrees to hold the seller harmless for delay — often including any consequential damages.
Meanwhile you may have a rate lock with an expiration, a lease with a notice period, and movers booked.
There is also usually a clause stating that incomplete repairs, touchups or adjustments are not a valid reason to refuse to close. You can be obliged to close on a house with an open punch list.
What a reasonable clause would look like
This is drafting guidance rather than a market standard, but it is what to ask for:
- An outside completion date, not merely an estimate.
- Force majeure limited to defined events, with a cap on cumulative extension days.
- A per-diem credit past the outside date, or your right to terminate with a full deposit refund.
- No obligation to close with material punch items outstanding — or an escrow holdback covering them.
- Who pays for a rate lock extension caused by builder delay.
That last one matters more than it sounds. If the contract disclaims delay liability and your lock expires because the builder slipped, the extension cost lands on you. Ask the question before you sign and get the answer in writing.
Clauses worth reading closely
Mandatory arbitration
Commonly the buyer’s sole and exclusive remedy, with an express jury trial waiver that survives closing. Some contracts add a fee-shifting penalty: a buyer who sues instead of arbitrating pays the builder’s attorney fees, court costs and litigation expenses.
Waiver of implied warranties
Language expressly waiving warranty requirements granted under federal, state, county and local law, leaving only the limited express warranty. Whether this is enforceable varies by state and is worth a local attorney’s eye.
One-way assignment
Buyers typically cannot assign the contract without the seller’s written permission, while the seller reserves the right to assign without the buyer’s consent.
Material substitution
Sellers commonly reserve the right to substitute materials, appliances, equipment and fixtures of equal or greater quality, with the buyer acknowledging no entitlement to compensation. Plans are subject to minor changes, colors may vary from samples, and brand names are frequently read as “or equal” at the seller’s discretion.
If a specific finish or appliance genuinely matters to you, get it named in the contract as a non-substitutable item, or expect what arrives to be the builder’s choice.
Price escalation
Some contracts let the seller raise the price if material or labor costs rise beyond a threshold, with the buyer given a short window — five calendar days in the contract we reviewed — to accept or the seller cancels.
Inspector restrictions
Credential requirements on your inspector, plus language stating the seller is not governed by outside inspections and may decline work beyond its own criteria. Negotiate inspection access before signing.
Non-disparagement
Often present, and very likely unenforceable. The Consumer Review Fairness Act voids provisions in consumer form contracts that restrict reviews of a seller’s goods, services or conduct or impose penalties for them, and the Federal Trade Commission has enforced it.
Your agent, and the first-visit rule
You can absolutely use your own agent on new construction, and you should. The on-site sales agent is a pleasant, knowledgeable professional who works for the builder, not for you.
Since the August 2024 changes to how buyer-agent compensation works, offers of compensation can no longer be published on the MLS, and buyers sign a written agreement with their agent before touring. Builders were never MLS-bound in the first place, so builder-paid buyer-agent compensation is now a direct negotiation with the builder, usually settled at or before your first visit.
Which brings up the rule that catches people: most builders require your agent to register you, or accompany you, on your first visit — otherwise the commission is forfeited and you may find yourself unrepresented or paying your agent out of pocket.
We could not verify that this is universal across all builders, and we would rather say so than state it as a rule. But it is consistently reported, it is unforgiving where it applies, and the fix costs nothing: do not walk into a model home alone if you intend to use an agent. Bring them, or have them register you in advance.
What to negotiate, in priority order
Builders negotiate less on price than resale sellers do, because a recorded low sale price affects the appraisals of every other home in the subdivision. They negotiate considerably more on terms and incentives, which is where to spend your effort.
- A financing contingency with a deadline and a deposit refund, if there is not one.
- Escrow protection for the entire deposit, including any construction deposit.
- An outside completion date with a remedy — per-diem credit or termination with refund.
- Inspection access rights at pre-drywall and final walkthrough, with workable credential requirements.
- An escrow holdback for punch items, since you will likely be obliged to close regardless.
- Who pays for a rate lock extension if the builder is late.
- Named, non-substitutable items for anything that genuinely matters to you.
- Incentives — the area with the most give, especially on completed standing inventory.
And one general note: nearly everything above is easier to change before you sign than after. Builder sales agents will often tell you the contract is standard and cannot be modified. That is true of some clauses and untrue of others, and the way to find out which is to ask in writing and see what comes back.
Frequently asked questions
Is my deposit refundable on a new construction home?
Often not. Builder contracts commonly split the money into escrowed earnest money refundable only under narrow triggers, plus a separate construction deposit that is explicitly non-refundable if you do not close. They also frequently omit the loan, appraisal and inspection objection deadlines that state resale forms provide. Assume it is not refundable unless the contract says otherwise in writing.
Can I get a financing contingency on a builder contract?
Often yes, but you usually have to ask — many builder agreements omit one by default. It is one of the most valuable things to negotiate before signing, especially on completed standing inventory where the builder has more incentive to close a deal.
What happens if the builder finishes late?
Usually nothing, contractually. Builder agreements typically give an estimated occupancy rather than a firm date, allow extension for weather and acts of God, and have the buyer hold the seller harmless for delay damages. Ask for an outside completion date with a per-diem credit or termination right, and clarify in writing who pays for a rate lock extension caused by builder delay.
Do I have to close if the punch list is not finished?
Under most builder contracts, yes — they commonly state that incomplete repairs, touchups or adjustments are not valid grounds to refuse to close. The practical protection is an escrow holdback negotiated in writing before closing day, with dollar amounts attached to the outstanding items.
Can I use my own agent to buy new construction?
Yes, and you should — the on-site sales agent works for the builder. Since August 2024, builder-paid buyer-agent compensation is a direct negotiation with the builder rather than an MLS offer. Most builders require your agent to register or accompany you on your first visit, so do not tour a model home alone if you intend to be represented.
Can a builder substitute different materials than what I picked?
Typically yes. Builder contracts commonly reserve the right to substitute materials, appliances, equipment and fixtures of equal or greater quality, with the buyer acknowledging no entitlement to compensation, and treat brand names as “or equal” at the seller’s discretion. If a specific item matters, have it named as non-substitutable in the contract.
Do builders negotiate on price?
Less than resale sellers, because a recorded low sale price affects the appraisals of every other home in the subdivision. They negotiate considerably more on incentives and contract terms, which is where to focus — especially on completed inventory that is already costing them money to hold.
Should I have a lawyer review a builder contract?
For a first-time buyer, it is one of the better few hundred dollars you can spend. Builder agreements are seller-drafted, frequently include binding arbitration with a jury waiver, waive implied warranties to a degree that varies by state, and structure deposits toward forfeiture. Nearly all of it is easier to address before signing than after.