First-Time Home Buyer Loan Programs Compared: FHA, USDA, VA & Conventional

Choosing your loan is the single biggest financial decision of your first home purchase — it shapes your down payment, your monthly cost, and how much house you can afford. The good news: for first-time buyers, four programs cover almost everyone. Here’s how they compare, in plain English.

The four programs at a glance

  • FHA loan — 3.5% down, credit scores from ~580. The most forgiving on credit. Tradeoff: mortgage insurance usually lasts the life of the loan.
  • USDA loan — 0% down in eligible (often surprisingly suburban) areas, with income limits. Unbeatable if you qualify by location.
  • VA loan — 0% down, no monthly mortgage insurance, for veterans and active-duty service members. Almost always the best deal if you’re eligible.
  • Conventional 97 / HomeReady / Home Possible — 3% down for first-time and lower-income buyers. Best long-term cost if your credit is strong (~680+), because you can drop PMI at 20% equity.

How to think about which is right for you

Start with the two zero-down options. If you or your spouse served in the military, a VA loan is usually the clear winner. If not, check whether the home’s address is USDA-eligible — the map is broader than “rural” implies, and a no-down-payment loan is hard to beat.

If neither fits, it comes down to your credit. Scores in the high-500s to low-600s usually point to FHA. Scores around 680 and up often make a conventional 3%-down loan cheaper over time, because you can cancel private mortgage insurance once you build 20% equity — something FHA generally won’t let you do.

Remember: whichever loan you pick, you can often stack down payment assistance or a grant on top of it to cover your down payment and closing costs. And your loan choice interacts with your credit score — improving your score even a little before you apply can change which programs are open to you.

Not sure where you stand? Our complete first-time buyer guide walks through the whole picture, money and process.


The mortgage insurance rules are the whole decision

Buyers compare interest rates. Rates between these programs are usually within a quarter point of each other, and the quarter point is not what decides the total cost. Mortgage insurance is — specifically, whether it ever goes away.

On a conventional loan, private mortgage insurance is temporary. Once you have paid down to 80% of the original value, you can request cancellation in writing, and at 78% the lender must drop it automatically whether you ask or not. Those thresholds are federal law, not lender policy.

On an FHA loan, mortgage insurance is usually permanent. If you put down less than 10%, the annual premium runs for the entire life of the loan. Put down 10% or more and it drops off after 11 years. There is no paying-down-to-a-threshold escape and no requesting cancellation — the only way out of FHA mortgage insurance on a low-down-payment loan is to refinance into a conventional loan later, which means qualifying again at whatever rates exist then.

That single asymmetry is worth more over a decade than any rate difference you are likely to be shown.

What each program actually charges you

FHA

1.75% of the loan amount upfront, which is normally rolled into the balance rather than paid in cash, plus an annual premium of 0.55% at under 5% down or 0.50% at 5% down or more, divided into your monthly payment. Minimum credit score is 580 for the 3.5% down payment; between 500 and 579 you need 10% down. For 2026 the FHA limit runs from $541,287 in most of the country up to $1,249,125 in the highest-cost counties.

VA

No down payment, and — the part that gets buried — no monthly mortgage insurance at all. Instead there is a one-time funding fee: 2.15% on your first use with nothing down, 3.3% if you have used the benefit before. Putting 5% down cuts it to 1.5%, and 10% down to 1.25%.

The fee is waived entirely if you receive VA compensation for a service-connected disability, are entitled to it but take retirement or active-duty pay instead, are a surviving spouse receiving DIC, have a proposed or memorandum rating before closing, or were awarded a Purple Heart on or before your closing date. If any of those apply and the fee appears on your closing disclosure anyway, that is an error worth catching before you sign.

USDA

1% of the loan amount upfront and 0.35% annually. Household income has to be at or below 115% of area median. Two things surprise people: the eligible map covers far more than genuinely remote land — plenty of ordinary suburbs qualify — and since October 2025 USDA has been issuing commitments subject to available funding authority, so a USDA file can face timing risk that an FHA or VA file does not.

Conventional

3% down through HomeReady or Home Possible if your income is at or below 80% of area median, or through the standard 97% program with no income cap if at least one borrower is a first-time buyer. The 2026 conforming limit is $832,750 in most counties and $1,249,125 in high-cost areas.

Your credit score is a price on a conventional loan and a gate on an FHA loan

This is the cleanest way to work out which program you belong in, and almost nobody explains it.

Conventional pricing is graded by credit score through loan-level price adjustments. On a purchase at 80 to 85% loan-to-value, the adjustment runs about 0.375% of the loan for a borrower at 780 and above, and about 2.875% for a borrower at 639 and below — roughly a two and a half point swing in upfront cost, or something like half a point of rate. Private mortgage insurance is also priced by credit score, so a lower score gets charged twice.

FHA does none of this. The upfront and annual premiums are identical at 580 and at 780. FHA, VA, USDA and Section 184 loans are all exempt from those adjustments entirely.

The practical consequence: below roughly 680 to 700, FHA usually wins on monthly cost even with permanent mortgage insurance, because conventional is charging you twice for the score. Above that, conventional usually wins, because the insurance eventually stops. If you are near the line, the honest move is to ask a lender to price both and compare the five-year total — not the rate.

Two 2026 changes worth knowing

FHA tightened its residency rules. Since May 2025, non-permanent resident aliens are no longer eligible for FHA-insured mortgages; the program is now limited to U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents. A great many guides still say otherwise. If you are on a visa, conventional financing is the route.

Credit scoring is changing. As of 2026, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and FHA all accept VantageScore 4.0 and FICO 10T alongside the classic FICO models — the first change in decades. The practical upside is that documented rent payment history can now count toward your score, which matters most for exactly the buyers these programs exist for. Ask your lender which model they are pulling.

How to compare two real offers

When you have loan estimates in hand, ignore the headline rate and compare three numbers: total monthly payment including mortgage insurance and escrow, total cash needed at closing, and what the payment becomes once mortgage insurance drops off — which for FHA under 10% down is never. A conventional loan that costs $40 a month more today and sheds $180 of insurance in year seven is not the more expensive loan.

Renovation and repair financing


Choosing between loans


Other ways to buy

  • Assumable mortgages — Taking over a seller’s low-rate FHA, VA or USDA loan.
  • HUD homes — Buying an FHA foreclosure with $100 down, and the 2025 priority-window changes.
  • Buying a foreclosed home — Auctions, bank-owned homes, HomePath and HomeSteps.
  • Short sales — How lender-approved sales work and how long they take.
  • Rent-to-own homes — Lease-options vs lease-purchases, and the risks.
  • Build vs. buy — What it really costs to build, and construction loan options.

More on choosing a loan


Outside the agency box

  • Non-QM loans — What they really are, why ability-to-repay still applies, and when to say no.