You budgeted for the mortgage. The mortgage is the predictable part.
What catches new owners is everything around it — insurance that has risen 18% to 43% in real terms since 2018, a tax bill that jumps in year two, and maintenance that arrives in lumps rather than monthly instalments. Modeled estimates put the full cost of owning and maintaining a typical single-family home at over $21,000 a year on top of the loan.
This page covers the costs that show up after closing, with honest sourcing about which figures are solid and which are folklore.
Homeowners insurance is the fastest-rising line item
If one number should change how you shop for a house, it is this one.
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners published its first national homeowners market analysis in August 2026, covering 2018 through 2024. Inflation-adjusted average premium per policy rose between 18.3% and 43.3% across every region of the country — roughly 2.4% to 5.3% a year, after inflation. Company-initiated non-renewal rates rose between 96% and 216% depending on region.
That second figure matters as much as the first. Insurers are not just charging more, they are declining to renew.
What it costs now
National averages vary by methodology, so the coverage level matters when comparing quotes. One major analysis puts the national average at $2,872 a year at $300,000 dwelling coverage. Another puts it at $2,490 at $400,000 coverage.
The state spread is enormous:
- Florida: about $8,471 a year — the highest in the country, driven by hurricane exposure and litigation frequency.
- Oklahoma: about $7,255 — tornado and hail.
- Nebraska: about $6,015.
- Texas: about $4,915.
- Colorado: about $3,910 — wildfire.
A caution on the cheap end: Hawaii shows as the least expensive at roughly $738 to $900, but that excludes hurricane coverage, which requires a separate policy there. It is not genuinely cheap.
We also want to flag honestly that sources disagree sharply on some states — Louisiana appears at $2,020 in one dataset and far higher in others, and the two are not reconcilable. Treat single-state averages as directional and get an actual quote.
The practical instruction
Get an insurance quote on a specific address before your inspection contingency expires, not after. In Florida, Oklahoma, Louisiana, Texas, Colorado and increasingly California, the premium can be a four-figure annual difference between two houses on the same street depending on roof age, construction and claims history.
Buyers routinely shop mortgage rates to save $40 a month and never shop insurance, where the spread can be several times larger.
The truth about the 1% maintenance rule
You will read everywhere that you should budget 1% of your home’s value annually for maintenance. We went looking for the study behind it.
There isn’t one. We could find no research establishing 1% of home value as a validated maintenance figure. It is a heuristic that got repeated until it sounded like data, and we think you deserve to know that.
What the actual evidence shows points in two directions:
- Survey data on what owners report spending: about $2,041 a year on maintenance plus $1,143 on emergency repairs — roughly $3,184 combined. Against a median home around $433,000, that is well under 1%.
- Modeled total-cost estimates: maintenance of about $8,808 a year, which is closer to 2%.
The gap between those is the difference between what people report spending and what a house actually consumes, including deferred work that eventually comes due.
A more useful way to think about it
The 1% rule is a reasonable savings target, not a prediction. Actual spending is lumpy — nothing for three years, then $14,000 for a roof.
And critically, maintenance cost tracks age and square footage far more than value. A 1,400 square foot 1962 house in Cleveland and a 1,400 square foot 1962 house in San Jose need the same roof, and the roof costs roughly the same. But 1% of value would budget $2,000 for one and $12,000 for the other.
So the rule systematically over-budgets in expensive coastal markets and under-budgets in cheaper markets with older housing stock. If you are buying a older home in the Midwest or the South, 1% of value is probably not enough. If you are buying a newer home in an expensive metro, it is probably more than you need.
Better approach: budget by what is actually going to fail. Find out the age of the roof, HVAC, water heater and windows during inspection, look up replacement costs locally, divide each by its remaining years, and save that. It takes an hour and it is a real number rather than a folk rule.
The year-two property tax jump
Covered in more depth in our guide to escrow, but it belongs on any honest list of hidden costs.
If you buy from someone who owned the house a long time, the assessed value on record may be far below what you just paid. Many jurisdictions reassess at the sale price after a transfer. Your first year of escrow was built on the previous owner’s tax bill. Your second year is built on yours.
Stack that with rising insurance, repayment of the resulting escrow shortage, and a recalculated escrow cushion, and a payment that was $2,400 can become $2,700 without your rate changing at all.
The fix is fifteen minutes of work before you close: look up the property’s current assessed value and your local tax rate, calculate the bill at your purchase price, and budget for that figure rather than the one on your Loan Estimate.
Everything else that arrives after closing
Immediately
- Moving — $1,500 to $5,000 for a local professional move, more long-distance.
- Utility deposits and connection fees — a few hundred dollars, and often a surprise for former renters whose utilities were bundled.
- Immediate repairs — the things inspection found that you accepted rather than negotiated.
- The empty-house problem — window coverings, a lawn mower, a ladder, basic tools, a second set of everything you shared in an apartment. Budget $2,000 to $5,000 and you will still be surprised.
Ongoing
- HOA dues if applicable — and note that these can be raised, and that special assessments for major repairs are separate and can run into thousands.
- Utilities you did not pay as a renter — water, sewer, trash, and the fact that a house costs far more to heat and cool than an apartment with shared walls.
- Lawn and yard — either your time or roughly $100 to $200 a month.
- Pest control in much of the South.
- Higher electricity — a common shock when moving from a small apartment to a full house.
The one people forget entirely
Your emergency fund needs to be bigger now, not the same. As a renter, a broken furnace was a phone call. As an owner it is $6,000 and it does not wait.
A reasonable target is three to six months of expenses plus a separate home reserve of at least $5,000 to $10,000. Buying a house that leaves you with no cash buffer is the single most common way first-time owners end up in trouble, and it is far more dangerous than a slightly higher rate.
What this means for how much house to buy
Modeled estimates put the total annual cost of owning and maintaining a typical single-family home — not counting the mortgage principal — at over $21,000, with a range from roughly $12,600 in West Virginia to about $34,600 in Hawaii.
You do not have to accept those figures to take the point: the mortgage is perhaps 60% to 70% of what the house actually costs you each year.
A concrete way to use this. Before you finalize your budget, add up:
- Principal and interest on the loan you are considering.
- Property taxes at your purchase price, after reassessment — not the seller’s current bill.
- An actual insurance quote for that specific address.
- Mortgage insurance if you are putting less than 20% down.
- HOA dues if any.
- A maintenance figure built from the age of the roof, HVAC and water heater rather than from 1% of value.
- Utilities estimated from the seller’s actual bills — you can ask for these, and a reasonable seller will provide them.
If that total makes you uncomfortable, buy less house. That is a far better outcome than discovering it in month fourteen when the water heater goes.
None of this is an argument against buying. It is an argument for buying with the real number in front of you, which is what everyone deserves and what very few first-time buyers are actually shown.
Frequently asked questions
How much should I budget for home maintenance?
The common advice is 1% of home value annually, but we could find no research establishing that figure — it is a heuristic, not data. Survey data on reported spending comes to roughly $3,184 a year, while modeled estimates put it near $8,808. Maintenance tracks a home’s age and size far more than its value, so budget from the actual age of your roof, HVAC and water heater instead.
Why is homeowners insurance rising so fast?
Regulators found inflation-adjusted premiums rose 18.3% to 43.3% across every US region between 2018 and 2024, with company-initiated non-renewals up 96% to 216%. It is now the fastest-growing line item in homeownership, and in high-risk states it can differ by thousands between two houses on the same street.
Which states have the most expensive homeowners insurance?
Florida is highest at roughly $8,471 a year, followed by Oklahoma at about $7,255, Nebraska around $6,015, Texas about $4,915 and Colorado about $3,910. Hawaii appears cheapest at $738 to $900 but that excludes hurricane coverage, which requires a separate policy there.
Why did my property taxes go up after I bought?
Many jurisdictions reassess at the sale price when a property transfers. If you bought from a long-time owner, the assessed value on record was likely well below what you paid, so your first-year escrow was built on their bill and your second year on yours. Calculate the tax at your purchase price before you close.
How much emergency fund do I need as a homeowner?
More than as a renter. A reasonable target is three to six months of expenses plus a separate home reserve of $5,000 to $10,000. As a renter a broken furnace is a phone call; as an owner it is a $6,000 bill that will not wait. Buying with no cash buffer is a more common cause of trouble than a slightly higher interest rate.
What does it actually cost to own a home per year beyond the mortgage?
Modeled estimates put total annual ownership and maintenance costs above $21,000 for a typical single-family home, ranging from roughly $12,600 in West Virginia to about $34,600 in Hawaii. Broadly, the mortgage is only 60% to 70% of what a house costs you each year.
Should I get an insurance quote before making an offer?
Before your inspection contingency expires, at minimum. In Florida, Oklahoma, Louisiana, Texas, Colorado and increasingly California, premiums vary by thousands based on roof age, construction type and claims history. Buyers routinely shop mortgage rates to save $40 a month while never shopping insurance, where the spread is often several times larger.
What upfront costs come right after closing?
Moving at $1,500 to $5,000, utility deposits and connection fees, any repairs you accepted rather than negotiated, and the cost of furnishing a house rather than an apartment — window coverings, yard equipment, tools. Budget $2,000 to $5,000 for that last category and expect to exceed it.
Keep reading
- How much cash you actually need to buy a house
- How mortgage escrow works
- Property taxes for first-time buyers
- Home inspections
- HOAs explained
Related reading
- Are home warranties worth it? — What the contracts actually cover, and what the enforcement record shows.